Progressives have an unhealthy infatuation with the future. They project it onto the canvas of today, so bright and glamorous that they blind themselves to practical problems that are right under their noses.
Canadians may remember when Prime Minister Justin Trudeau declared the death of the resource economy. At the World Economic Forum in Davos in 2016, he told the world, “My predecessor wanted you to know Canada for its resources. I want you to know Canadians for our resourcefulness.” The following year he told a town hall in Peterborough, Ont., “We can’t shut down the [Alberta] oilsands tomorrow. We need to phase them out.” Someone had likely instructed him that the future belonged to jobs in tech, knowledge jobs for sophisticated intellectual creators to deliver in telehealth, corporate services, finance, consulting and such.
One may also remember the denigrating air toward blue-collar and trade jobs, which Trudeau’s policies treated as toxically masculine. At the G20 summit in Buenos Aires in 2018, he spoke of the “gender impacts when you bring construction workers into a rural area,” on a panel where he also discussed “toxic masculinity.” In the obtuse, future-bound intellect of progressive visionaries like him, the effect of such jobs on small (read non-progressive) towns needed careful study under intersectional lenses, in the hope of stripping the workers of their troglodyte habits of body and mind.
The 2019 Impact Assessment Act wrote the vision into law: section 22(1)(s) requires every federal review of a major project to weigh “the intersection of sex and gender with other identity factors.” These workers were the folks Scott Reid, Paul Martin’s director of communications, had in mind in 2005, when he warned against giving parents a $25-a-week child-care allowance “to blow on beer and popcorn.” Subsidies and tax breaks for artists, on the other hand, greatly benefit society.
The proclaimed preference comes with handsome endowments for special university chairs to validate the intersectional future progressives desire for you and to find ways to implement it. In May 2017, Ottawa told universities to meet equity targets for their Canada Research Chairs by December 2019, or have payments for new nominations withheld. The chairholders would bring that future to life in thought and deed. They would reach into that future with their insightful minds and pull it into the present.
A few examples illustrate the point. The University of Alberta holds a Tier 1 Canada Research Chair in Feminism and Intersectionality, for which Ottawa pays the university $200,000 a year for seven years. Its holder announced in December 2020 a research program on anti-BIPOC racism and decolonization in the universities of five “settler colonial states”: Canada, Brazil, South Africa, Sweden and Finland. In March 2021, the University of British Columbia advertised for a Canada Research Chair in Queer Indigenous Cultural Production.
The Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, for its part, paid $94,000 in 2018 to study the rhetoric of the selfie. A Canadian Taxpayers Federation review of the federal grant records, published in 2025, found $93,000 for “The Erotics of Rule-Following in British Romanticism,” $17,500 for “Disgraced Former Rodeo Princesses,” $73,786 for “Are Kinksters Doing It Better?” and $58,000 for “Fat Chair: Thickening Design Standards through Fat Studies.” This is the world that sustained Naheed Nenshi.
That education is a provincial domain under section 93 of the Constitution Act, 1867, does not matter. The dashing brilliance of woke intellect would serve as a Trojan horse against provincial jurisdiction and the traditional academy, pulling them, kicking and screaming, into an idyllic social and economic future. Ottawa tried the same with resource projects and trade workers, and on Oct. 13, 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled 5 to 2 that the Impact Assessment Act’s scheme for designated projects reached beyond federal jurisdiction.
Haultain Research is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. You may also support us by sharing our work with like-minded friends and family, or making a modest donation at www.haultain.org.
Trudeau may be gone, but ambassadors of his vision roam among us. The Alberta consul of such enlightenment is former Mount Royal University professor Naheed Nenshi, leader of the Alberta NDP.
When he released his party’s economic strategy on Nov. 10, Nenshi lamented a time “when traditional jobs are being impacted [sic] by automation and AI.” Three days later, Education Minister Demetrios Nicolaides announced new high school graduation requirements: from the fall of 2028, students will need 47 credits in core subjects instead of 56, leaving room for up to 53 credits in options such as the skilled trades. Nenshi called learning more skills a lowering of standards. “The UCP seems to think that public schools are factories for workers for jobs of the past,” he said. In the legislature on Nov. 16, he added that the premier must think tradespeople need no math, science, English or history.
There was a time in which Canada’s workers’ party would have hailed factories. Today, only factories for woke indoctrination are A-OK.
Premier Danielle Smith answered him in question period that same day. Trades are not jobs of the past, she said, and tradespeople are at work in Calgary right now “fixing his broken water pipes.” Zing! The premier’s remark underlines the obtuse vision that makes progressives miss the forest for the trees.
Yesterday’s jobs, as the NDP leader calls them, give us today’s energy to heat our homes, cook our meals and drive our children to school and hockey practices. Yesterday’s jobs build homes (when progressive regulatory obstruction isn’t strangling them) to house ourselves, the newcomers and those living in tents on the streets of our larger cities.
Yesterday’s jobs repair the grids and power lines that reliably illuminate our classrooms, clinics, and operating rooms. Yesterday’s jobs build and maintain roads for Teslas and F-150s alike.
Yesterday’s jobs are the jobs, stopped by municipal managers and clever councillors in Calgary, that build and maintain the water and sewage systems on which the health and economy of cities have depended since ancient Rome.
Without yesterday’s jobs, and the people with unacceptable views who hold them, there is no modern life, no amenities, no cable repairs, no stage builders in theatres, no garbage pickup and sidewalk repairs, no mechanics and carpenters.
Just societies have learned to value manual labour and to give those who perform it the respect and parity of esteem their roles require. Without the doers to accomplish the practical things everyone needs, we will be left with managers and planners designing mind-numbing lineups ruled by equity cards, and harebrained DEI schemes driven by ideological imperatives that are divorced from reality.
That’s the world left Calgarians in the hands of managers and councillors who postponed badly needed maintenance of vital water mains.
The record in the wake of such progressive thinking left Canada, since 2015, with falling real wages and higher prices, scores of homeless people and people dying on the streets, high crime and lower productivity, greater numbers lining up at food banks and too few houses being built, less investment coming in and more leaving the country.
Consumer prices rose 27 per cent between 2015 and 2024, and inflation cut the real average hourly wage 3.7 per cent between 2020 and 2022. On a single night in the fall of 2024, counters found nearly 60,000 people homeless in 74 communities, and 53,308 Canadians died of opioid poisoning between January 2016 and June 2025. Statistics Canada’s violent crime severity index stood 29 per cent higher in 2025 than in 2015. In March 2024, the Bank of Canada’s senior deputy governor, Carolyn Rogers, called the country’s weak productivity an emergency. Food bank visits reached 2.17 million in March 2025, double the 2019 count. Housing starts reached 259,000 in 2025, against the 417,000 to 469,000 a year that Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. says the country needs. The gap between Canadian direct investment abroad and foreign direct investment in Canada grew from $261 billion in 2015 to $971 billion in 2024. This is the future that the progressive visions of 2015 brought us.
A properly balanced society has room for everyone choosing freely what they want to do to thrive. A properly functioning government ensures everyone can choose for themselves. Places where the state and politicians choose for others and close off opportunities, or usher people onto paths drawn from ideological prejudices, are never the most desirable places to live.
The country showed the woke dilettante Trudeau and his half-baked philosophies the door. Albertans will have their chance at the general election set for October 2027, to hand his consul in Edmonton, Professor Nenshi, his hat, cane and overcoat.



Oh I remember those horrible accusations in Buenos Aires - he also used the word "r a p i s t s" to label those rural toxic masculines. I'm sorry, but I have experienced it differently. We are rural folk that work our asses off to help feed the nation. I used to be proud of that, but no longer. The primary production of everything that is needed in the urban areas is produced in rural areas by those toxic masculines and feminines. And they hate us for it!
Who are the troglodytes.? Why those that have to keep those elbows up to prevent their knuckles from dragging on the ground. I'm sure they think all their food comes from Safeway, magically wrapped and ready to eat.
Well said.