Three initial steps toward abolishing the Indian Act: a firm deadline, First Nations land ownership, and interim legal protections. Drawing on Frontier research, he argues reform must secure autonomy without leaving communities exposed.
Great article, Marco. But there has always been a hundred ways to do it. But things usually take the path of least resistance. In this case, the quick and dirty, the easiest way to deal with it, the path of least resistance is to throw more money at it. That way, you can come out with crocodile tears - think Justin Trudeau - and say that we are putting all this money into it and establishing a commission, etc etc etc. And, then skip the meetings and go windsurfing on a Tofino beach. In fairness, that was specifically the residential school solution, but for the most part, the First Nations solutions are invariably the same.
Bill C-428 received Royal Assent on December 16, 2014, amending Canada's Indian Act to remove outdated clauses, change how band bylaws are enacted, and require annual reports on replacing the act.
Key Changes
• Repealed Residential School Provisions: Removed sections 114 through 122 relating to residential schools and forcible child removal.
• Band Council Bylaws: Removed Ministerial oversight and disallowance powers (section 82) for general and intoxicant bylaws, allowing First Nations to publish bylaws online or in print directly. Taxation bylaws under section 83 still require Ministerial approval.
• Annual Reporting: Mandated periodic or annual ministerial reports <5>regarding steps to replace the Indian Act.
Criticisms and Ongoing Impact
• Mixed Reception: While proponents praised the removal of racist and obsolete language, critics argued the changes did not go far enough or replace the colonial framework with true collaborative reform.
• Bylaw Enforcement Issues: Eliminating federal review and ministerial disallowance created challenges for on-reserve bylaw enforcement, leaving questions around legal validity and Charter compliance for police services like the RCMP.
Great article, Marco. But there has always been a hundred ways to do it. But things usually take the path of least resistance. In this case, the quick and dirty, the easiest way to deal with it, the path of least resistance is to throw more money at it. That way, you can come out with crocodile tears - think Justin Trudeau - and say that we are putting all this money into it and establishing a commission, etc etc etc. And, then skip the meetings and go windsurfing on a Tofino beach. In fairness, that was specifically the residential school solution, but for the most part, the First Nations solutions are invariably the same.
bill c428 2014 Canada
Bill C-428 received Royal Assent on December 16, 2014, amending Canada's Indian Act to remove outdated clauses, change how band bylaws are enacted, and require annual reports on replacing the act.
Key Changes
• Repealed Residential School Provisions: Removed sections 114 through 122 relating to residential schools and forcible child removal.
• Repealed Outdated Clauses: Deleted sections 32–33 (produce sale/barter restrictions), section 36 (church/charitable trust lands), section 92 (unlicensed trading), and section 105 (legal identification).
• Band Council Bylaws: Removed Ministerial oversight and disallowance powers (section 82) for general and intoxicant bylaws, allowing First Nations to publish bylaws online or in print directly. Taxation bylaws under section 83 still require Ministerial approval.
• Annual Reporting: Mandated periodic or annual ministerial reports <5>regarding steps to replace the Indian Act.
Criticisms and Ongoing Impact
• Mixed Reception: While proponents praised the removal of racist and obsolete language, critics argued the changes did not go far enough or replace the colonial framework with true collaborative reform.
• Bylaw Enforcement Issues: Eliminating federal review and ministerial disallowance created challenges for on-reserve bylaw enforcement, leaving questions around legal validity and Charter compliance for police services like the RCMP.
Sponsored by MP Rob Clarke (Desnethe-Missinippi-Churchill River)