In 2017, candidate Jeromy Farkas wanted every Calgary department to compete for its work. Now Mayor Farkas defends a 15 per cent tax hike. Indianapolis shows the better way. Will Farkas remember his own words?
Insightful and thought provoking as always, Dr. MNG! A short book by Ludwig von Mises titled Bureaucracy gives analysis on the forces behind the outcomes you describe here. Whenever revenue is coerced and failures shielded from consequences we see what is unfolding now.
Excellent article. It seems that people get elected on a list of promises, then spend the next 4 years explaining why they can't keep those promises. 🤔
There is a ton the city could do better at including clearing their parking lots at their recreational facilities. The Glenmore pool parking lot was a extremely treacherous 2 days after the last snow fall. That is not okay when the majority of the clients going there are plus 50. They have the equipment and the means to do this but because the pool facilities are on run their own individual budgets they often won't use those funds to bring in the city to clean the parking lot. So, yes, the recreational facilities are on a budget and out of that budget they pay for the city's own services to have work done at their facility. It's the same reason they won't run more programming. Lifeguard costs. The City of Calgary by comparison to the rest of country pays far more and in some cases, up to $13 per hour more than some other major cities. All for fair wages but . . .
My frustration is the duplication of services across all three levels of government. In my community, for example, we have social programs funded by federal, provincial and municipal governments. That's one taxpayer contributing through three levels of taxation to support the same program. And there are many examples of overlapping funding and responsibilities.
If each level of government stayed within its own jurisdiction and eliminated unnecessary duplication, perhaps municipalities wouldn't need staggering property tax increases like the 15% proposed in Calgary.
I write this with absolutely no intention of being unkind: You are dreaming if you expect our current Council to allow anything to reduce the cost of running the City or to reduce the number of employees.
As I say, I mean no disrespect of unkindness; instead, I simply argue that the incentives for Council are directly opposite the desires of ratepayers for modest costs. I further argue that our "leaders" on Council are fully incented to act contrary to the interests of the citizenry.
And, having said all of that, I - as always - must praise your analysis, Sir.
The caption on the photos of Farkas…I think the one on the right should say 2026.
Superb article though.
Thank you for catching that silly mistake on the image. I changed it
Insightful and thought provoking as always, Dr. MNG! A short book by Ludwig von Mises titled Bureaucracy gives analysis on the forces behind the outcomes you describe here. Whenever revenue is coerced and failures shielded from consequences we see what is unfolding now.
Excellent article. It seems that people get elected on a list of promises, then spend the next 4 years explaining why they can't keep those promises. 🤔
There is a ton the city could do better at including clearing their parking lots at their recreational facilities. The Glenmore pool parking lot was a extremely treacherous 2 days after the last snow fall. That is not okay when the majority of the clients going there are plus 50. They have the equipment and the means to do this but because the pool facilities are on run their own individual budgets they often won't use those funds to bring in the city to clean the parking lot. So, yes, the recreational facilities are on a budget and out of that budget they pay for the city's own services to have work done at their facility. It's the same reason they won't run more programming. Lifeguard costs. The City of Calgary by comparison to the rest of country pays far more and in some cases, up to $13 per hour more than some other major cities. All for fair wages but . . .
My frustration is the duplication of services across all three levels of government. In my community, for example, we have social programs funded by federal, provincial and municipal governments. That's one taxpayer contributing through three levels of taxation to support the same program. And there are many examples of overlapping funding and responsibilities.
If each level of government stayed within its own jurisdiction and eliminated unnecessary duplication, perhaps municipalities wouldn't need staggering property tax increases like the 15% proposed in Calgary.
Fifteen percent! That's absolutely disgusting.
I write this with absolutely no intention of being unkind: You are dreaming if you expect our current Council to allow anything to reduce the cost of running the City or to reduce the number of employees.
As I say, I mean no disrespect of unkindness; instead, I simply argue that the incentives for Council are directly opposite the desires of ratepayers for modest costs. I further argue that our "leaders" on Council are fully incented to act contrary to the interests of the citizenry.
And, having said all of that, I - as always - must praise your analysis, Sir.